Help! Help!

I've heard this song many times over the last several years, and I never catch the name. It's a sweet, plaintive song. It's simple, quiet music and one male singer. I hear it in my head, but the only words I can remember - and they are not exactly the way they are in the song - are "I saw her at the [?]... last night/... and it goes like this/ the fourth, the fifth.../hallelujah, hallelujah"
If you caught the tv show Criminal Minds last night (in NYC,10/17), I think it played as the credits rolled. It sounded like Sting singing with his lute, but it wasn't.
IT'S DRIVING ME CRAZY ... PLEASE SAVE ME!!

Maybe Leonard Cohen's Hallelujah

YESSSSSSSSSSSS!! I can't thank you enough. xoxoxo