Something about God and a toothbrush

Ok, it's not much, but sometime in the early 2000's I heard a song a few times on the adult rock station (stuff like Alanis Morrisette, Matchbox 20, Staind, Natalie Merchant, etc.) that I still wonder about.

I believe it was a female singer and it was kind of a God exploring song (like "What If God Was One of Us" or "Counting Blue Cars")that referenced bunches of simple daily things, i.e. brushing teeth.

Does anyone have a clue?

It's not ringing any bells - have you tried contacting the station you used to hear it one? Sometimes they have a pretty good recollection of the music they used to play.