help with song title ? );

i was in ae about three weeks ago.
a song came on by panic at the disco, and i only got a glance and saw that the album was Pretty. Odd.
They played it like right after fergie - clumsy.
anyways i left before i got to see the song name, anyone know what it would be?
i really don't remember how it went.
but its not nine in the afternoon.

and i think it was like..
"some things are pretty odd"
or idk. :/

The line is 'Things are shaping up to be pretty odd' I think.
I just got the song it's The Green Gentleman