this mile

Thread: this mile

Tags: first song, pop punk, rhyme, sad song, second post
  1. Philip Wrobel said:

    Default this mile

    the first song i ever wrote, sry if it kinda sucks
    got the title wrong sorry, its supposed to be my mile

    my mile
    your smile
    the tile
    denial
    the maybes
    the save mes
    i know what you gaves me

    i wake up
    and pray that
    this is
    a dream
    but it still
    seems to
    be
    real

    i walk
    this mile
    my life
    in denial
    to see you
    smile
    and stay
    for a while

    you left
    me
    here
    upon the
    tile
    alone and
    no smile
    left here
    to walk
    my mile
    your smile
    the tile
    denial
    the maybes
    the save mes
    i know what you gaves me
    yes, i know what you gaves me
    you gaves me a smile
    an act of
    denial
    as you hit
    the tile
    Last edited by Philip Wrobel; 09-09-2012 at 02:19 AM. Reason: typo
     
  2. Doug Denslowe's Avatar

    Doug Denslowe said:

    Default

    Very clever!I like the way you posted it as well!Very unusual.Now that I've given you some feedback,feel free to give some other writers the same courtesy.
     
  3. Philip Wrobel said:

    Default

    alright will do
     
  4. Johnb31's Avatar

    Johnb31 said:

    Default

    I like this song too simple yet perfect. Check out some of my songs and poems on my thread tell me what u think.
    There is not enough space or time to truly let the song unwind
     
  5. Frankie Jasmine's Avatar

    Frankie Jasmine said:

    Default

    I like the e.e. cummings style of writing. It cuts to the quick. You are very clear when you write; no extraneous words or "fluff." That's not easy at your age (or any age!). Congrats on your first song. You can be proud of it.

    I believe that you are good enough that you deserve honest feedback; you are good enough that I think you can take it. So here are a couple things:

    Title: The title is fine, but if you want to change it: Click "Edit Post," then click "Go Advanced." There you can change it in the title-box if you wish.
    Changing of Title: Just an alternate consideration--it's in the poem also, "THIS MILE."
    Repetition in poem: I like the repetition of phrases (stanzas) and repetition of word useage (mes/maybes). The one that might need work IMHO is "gaves me":

    the maybes
    the save mes
    i know what you gaves me
    yes, i know what you gaves me . . .

    Some alternatives for your consideration--if you even choose to consider them:

    "gave mes"

    OR a change grammatically to:

    I know all the "gave mes" (referring back to what the other person perceives as having given "so much" to you).

    HOWEVER, if this gaves me is a flashback to a use of words between two people, and it needs to stay the same, you might consider putting it in quotes. This would alert the reader/hearer that it was a quirky, private "knowing" and way of speaking between the two. Instead of:

    I know what you gaves me

    How does this sound?

    I know all the "gaves me"
     
  6. Johnb31's Avatar

    Johnb31 said:

    Default

    Frankie you give so much time consuming feedback Im amazed by that. I wish I had more time to give in depth feedback you really help out a lot.
    There is not enough space or time to truly let the song unwind
     
  7. Philip Wrobel said:

    Default

    hahaha if anyone cares, i just realized that i sing this song to the same rhythm of blink 182's intro of apple shampoo
     
  8. Frankie Jasmine's Avatar

    Frankie Jasmine said:

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Johnb31 View Post
    Frankie you give so much time consuming feedback Im amazed by that. I wish I had more time to give in depth feedback you really help out a lot.
    When I'm into giving feedback, I don't do much writing of my own!
    When I glimpse talent, and someone trying, I feel they deserve a little bit of attention.
    I know I sure did.
    But thanks, John31!