A love song like a love song should be: simple, yet deep and heartfelt. I'm thinking two things: Just one man sitting on a stool, singing softly and strumming his guitar. Or a contemporary singer like Pink or Kelly Clarkson who has turned it into a dynamic powerballad.
Debeaux, this screams for a cool, swinging rhythm, remember Tamla Motown? One of their typical rhythmgroups might have been able to help you
bring your angel permanently back to where you want it most of all: in your arms! Great possibilities. WOW!