"He looked her in the eye, he said 'I don't love you'"

Can you help me find the artist or title of this song?
It is at the end of Brody and Doug's conversation about Stephanie's text messages, and continues into the scene where Darlene and Spencer go to lunch.

I've tried Google, I looked on the official MTV site (which is a terrible help, by the way) and my favorite fan site hasn't updated anything for season four yet!

Please help!