Ideas for "our song"

My boyfriend and me have been dating for 5 months now and we still have not found the perfect song. We have looked and thought of every song we know of. Little background to help: We were best friends before we started dating, We have NOT said "I Love You" yet, He is my first boyfriend, he has dated other people before me, we are both Christian, my friends don't always approve of us (and my teachers that have had both of us before) because they say I am too innocent and good for him. Our peers don't always seem to like us together either because we are mushy and hug each other lots. We have gotten a lot of comments about getting condoms(we believe in saving ourself till marriage so its not like we ever do anything bad), a room or "get some!" when literly we are only hugging goodbye before class.
some of the songs we have considered to get a idea of the type of music we like:
I'm yours by RON POPE (not jason maraz)
Still dreaming by idk who
you way with words is through silence by a day to remember
pretty baby by Vanessa Carlton
God blessed the broken road by rascal flatts
I miss you by lifehouse

I hope any of this helped give you ideas for songs, sorry I kinda rant at times. Please post lyrics if you can thanks in advance for any help.

Carmenita Lounging ~ Coco deMer with Claude Challe

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AFCYwmbSlzI

Hamayak Jan

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fmtYJ...layer_embedded

ΚΑΙΤΗ ΓΚΡΕΥ - ΚΑΘΕΝΑΣ ΜΕ ΤΟΝ ΠΟΝΟ ΤΟΥ

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w87oB...eature=related

I would like a song in English.. and its now been 6 months and we have said "I love you" now.

Originally Posted by skybaby!

I would like a song in English.. and its now been 6 months and we have said "I love you" now.

How about a song I wrote called, "I'll Hold Your Heart In My Soul"
http://soundcloud.com/slimcahill/if-...hould-ever-end

Slim