Untitled Thus Far

Thread: Untitled Thus Far

Tags: None
  1. Halberd's Avatar

    Halberd said:

    Default Untitled Thus Far

    So, I'm part of this band known as Halberd (Hence my log in name) and I wrote some lyrics I may be considering to suggest writing for. Now, we have other lyric capables, so I'd honestly like to know everything I can do to compete:

    With no innocence left
    We fought to the death
    But God no longer stood by our side

    Our doctrines scarcely alive
    Nobody left to revive -
    Liberty had already died

    For ignorance bound her
    Struggling I found her
    Bleeding from entangling wire

    With the last of her force
    She held up a torch
    But the Darkness had put out the fire

    So please save me
    I know where I stand!
    But through the killing
    When will it end?
    This tale took my soul
    I know that I'm damned
    But hate's all I know
    It's all anyone has
    It's all anyone has

    I've held captive a sound
    In a box long unwound
    'Till suddenly I gave it a wind

    The coils started to turn:
    My soul intangibly burned
    From songs reminiscent of a life left behind

    Yet that symphony's dead
    It's cry for help left unread
    I can't help but feel that all this was planned

    I claimed to hate war
    So I can't ask for more
    But no longer united we stand!

    So please save me
    I know where I stand!
    But through the killing
    When will it end?
    This tale took my soul
    I know that I'm damned
    But hate's all I know
    It's all anyone has
    It's all anyone has

    So please save me
    I'll hand you my life,
    Just break the silence
    Like the sun tears the night!
    This fog has me blinded
    Your apathy's might!
    Well here is my hatred
    How ironic the sight!
    Last edited by Halberd; 04-23-2008 at 05:32 PM.
     
  2. atmaestro's Avatar

    atmaestro said:

    Default

    Overall, I like the poem. The lines of the couplet in the first verse are slightly in conflict. The phrasing has death and loss of innocence as direct consequences and as a "destination" of fighting. My suggestion would be to make one as a destination and the other as the direct consequence of fighting. Such as:

    We fought to the death
    As our innocence left;
    God no longer stood by our side

    With no innocence left
    We fought to the death
    But God no longer stood by our side

    To me, the lines of the couplet in the second verse are repetitious. I would suggest a slight change to the first and/or second line so that the second line could appear to be independently paired with the 1st or third line.

    Our men no longer strive
    Nobody left to revive -
    Liberty had already died

    The second line of the third verse is awkward to me. Try something like:

    For ignorance had bound her
    Struggling I found her
    She was bleeding from entangling wire

    I like the fourth verse. The remainder of the poem has some more awkward moments but hopefully my previous suggestions will help you work those out.
    Them that can, do; them that can't... memorize Artist and Title
     
  3. Halberd's Avatar

    Halberd said:

    Default

    Thank you so much, this is absolutely wonderful feedback. I'll have an updated one posted as soon as I work out the newfound flaws, thanks man.

    With no innocence left
    We fought to the death
    But God no longer stood by our side

    Our doctrines scarcely alive
    Nobody left to revive -
    Liberty had already died

    For ignorance bound her
    Struggling I found her
    Bleeding from entangling wire

    With the last of her force
    She held up a torch
    But the Darkness had put out the fire

    So please save me
    I know where I stand!
    But through the killing
    When will it end?
    This tale took my soul
    I know that I'm damned
    But hate's all I know
    It's all anyone has
    It's all anyone has

    I've held captive a sound
    In a box long unwound
    'Till suddenly I gave it a wind

    The coils started to turn:
    My soul intangibly burned
    From songs reminiscent of a life left behind

    Yet that symphony's dead
    It's cry for help left unread
    I can't help but feel that all this was planned

    I claimed to hate war
    So I can't ask for more
    But no longer united we stand!

    So please save me
    I know where I stand!
    But through the killing
    When will it end?
    This tale took my soul
    I know that I'm damned
    But hate's all I know
    It's all anyone has
    It's all anyone has

    So please save me
    I'll hand you my life,
    Just break the silence
    Like the sun tears the night!
    This fog has me blinded
    Your apathy's might!
    Well here is my hatred
    How ironic the sight!
    Last edited by Halberd; 04-23-2008 at 05:32 PM.
    http://www.allthelyrics.com/forum/lyrics-review/40239-untitled-thus-far.html

    Want to better the world? Critique my lyrics ^^
     
  4. atmaestro's Avatar

    atmaestro said:

    Default

    Glad I could help.
    It definitely "flows" better with the changes you made.
    Them that can, do; them that can't... memorize Artist and Title
     
  5. Halberd's Avatar

    Halberd said:

    Default

    Thank you. I still have a problem though. This verse here:

    The coils started to turn:
    My soul intangibly burned
    From songs reminiscent of a life left behind

    And then these verses:

    I claimed to hate war
    So I can't ask for more
    But no longer united we stand!

    So please save me
    I know where I stand!
    But through the killing
    When will it end?
    This tale took my soul
    I know that I'm damned
    But hate's all I know
    It's all anyone has
    It's all anyone has

    The stand is too repeated there, but I don't want to change either of them too much... Any ideas?
    http://www.allthelyrics.com/forum/lyrics-review/40239-untitled-thus-far.html

    Want to better the world? Critique my lyrics ^^
     
  6. atmaestro's Avatar

    atmaestro said:

    Default

    Try the following lines for the first part:

    In a box long bound
    Was a captive sound
    ‘Til nameless strength its bondage pardoned

    My soul instantly burned
    From songs once interned
    Reminiscent of a life now abandoned

    Yet that symphony's dead
    It's cry for help unsaid
    I can't help but feel it was all planned

    I claimed to hate war
    And can endure no more
    For united no longer we stand!
    -----------------------------------------------------------

    It appears you are struggling with the final lines of the poem. You have vividly presented a conflict and now it's time to drive home your point/conclusion/solution (or not). The final lines attempt to show your uncertainty about the right or wrong of the situation and the hopelessness for a solution. My suggestion is to condense the rambling and bring it on home!
    Them that can, do; them that can't... memorize Artist and Title
     
  7. Halberd's Avatar

    Halberd said:

    Default

    Thanks, I really owe you, I think this is coming off alot better now.
    http://www.allthelyrics.com/forum/lyrics-review/40239-untitled-thus-far.html

    Want to better the world? Critique my lyrics ^^